Quantcast Vaccines Cause Autism?

Vaccines Cause Autism?

17
Comments

syringe.jpgIt seems like reports are coming out linking autism to vaccines. I had never put any thought into it, but it seems like there’s a link there. It could however be like Pirates and Global Warming where the two are unrelated coincidences.

The big news is that the United States government seems to be conceding a connection by compensating the family of a girl who has autism-like symptoms. The government officials deny that the money concedes that connection and says that it is “a very special situation.”

The article goes on to explain that the girl’s father is a neurologist. I imagine that make him more qualified to recognize the signs of autism in an 18-month girl. Her mother is also in the medical field – she’s a nurse. Lastly, the mother is trained as a lawyer. I wonder if the “very special situation” is the fact that these people are professionally able to link the autism to the vaccines AND be able to litigate it properly. The only thing that could be better is if the grandfather was the government official giving them the money.

Later in the article, they say that there is very little in the way of testing of vaccine-autism link. It doesn’t surprise me, I don’t know how you’d go about testing it. You certainly are not likely to have a control group of children who do not receive vaccines, right?

Featured Information

This post deals with: ... and focuses on:

Featured, News

Posted by Lazy Man on March 9, 2008 in Featured, News.

17 Responses to “Vaccines Cause Autism?”
  1. Brip Blap Says:

    It’s actually a very frightening subject if you have small kids. Until the root causes of autism are understood, there is no way to rule out the chemical in the vaccine (it’s a mercury derivative) but my understanding is they’ve quit using it, as well.

    I think they have every right to sue the government for this reason: in many states, vaccination is required by law. If you have some evidence that suggests the state is forcing you to take something that might hurt you, the state is responsible. Now, if vaccines were by choice, then fine. But I’ve been amazed in Jersey how the state rams vaccination down the throats of its citizens – no public school for unvaccinated children, for example.

    A co-worker of mine had a sister who had a normal, healthy son who, shortly after beginning his round of vaccinations, developed autistic characteristics. It of course could have been latent, caused by something else, etc. – but since I know someone who is now suffering with an autistic child it’s disturbing to me.

    Even more disturbing – there is some link between cow’s milk and autism, too.

    Oh well – the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. I guess the government figures a few kids with autism is better than a million with smallpox. That’s a whole difficult ethical argument there.

  2. FFB Says:

    I’ve heard about this and it’s damn scary. And why shouldn’t it sound scary? From what I understood it was a specific combination of vaccines that was suspect not necessarily the vaccines themselves.

  3. deepali Says:

    There is no link between vaccines and autism. None. Period. The only biologically plausible link was thimerosol, which has been removed from vaccines (and which babies cleared from their bodies too soon to see an effect anyway). Since then, we have not seen a decrease in the autism rate (actually, we’ve seen an increase). A pregnant mother’s fish consumption is a more likely cause of autism than vaccines.

    We don’t know the causes or even the mechanism of autism. Therefore, it’s impossible to make a claim of causality. The only possibly way to do so is through statistical analysis in a population-based study. And all such analysis done so far has shown no link. This girl’s parents are demonstrating a poor knowledge of both science and statistics in making this claim that they “know” what is causing their child’s autism.

    As for mandatory vaccines – I’m not going to get up on my soap box. Suffice to say that this is the downside of effective public health. No one notices our successes because our goal is prevention. Mandatory immunization is the reason our kids don’t die of horrible communicable diseases while young.
    Ok. That was a little soap box. :)

  4. Chief Family Officer Says:

    This is a hot issue among parents – I mean, no parent wants to feel that there was something they could have done to prevent their child from developing autism. It is certainly an issue that I researched before I had my first child, and something I talked about with his pediatrician. Fortunately for us, our pediatrician’s office only carries thimerosal-free vaccines (the mercury-containing preservative that is suspected as a cause). There is some thought that perhaps the MMR vaccine also causes autism, and at least one of my friends chose to have that broken up for that reason.

    For what it’s worth, our pediatrician is completely skeptical of the vaccine-autism connection. One of my former colleagues has a son who is autistic and we talked extensively about it since his daughter and my oldest were born around the same time. After his daughter was born, my colleague commented that his children were just totally different at the same age, with his daughter much more engaging than his son had ever been. I also know a couple of other people with children on the spectrum and the signs were present early. So I’ve become skeptical of the vaccine connection myself – which isn’t to say I don’t understand why the parents feel the way they do. But I think the article’s alternative theory – that the vaccines may have triggered something that was already there – is probably more viable. In my completely *un*expert opinion :)

  5. Billy Says:

    Thanks for blogging about this. This is a huge debate among bloggers (and parents) right now. Personally, I’m wary of the fact that vaccinations (including the flu shot) contain mercury.

    I linked to this post on Qvisory yesterday.

  6. Living Off Dividends Says:

    I saw a tv show on KPBS last year. It was a seminar presented at UCSD. Some doctor had shown that since mercury had started to be added in vaccines in the late 70s, there was a huge spike in number of autism cases. It seemed pretty convincing to me.

    I don’t know anything about this correlation except that if I was a parent, I’d be terrified!

  7. PhineusQButterfat Says:

    My wife’s cousin was born 100% normal and had her scheduled DPT shot when she was just months old. She is now 19, has the mental capacity of a 10 – 12 year old and had an operation to split her corpus callosum due to seizures and other complications. She had a reaction to the inoculation and was determined to be the cause of her abnormality. I can see this affecting people in similar ways resulting in autism.

  8. paidtwice Says:

    As a parent, and a parent of a child who has severe delays (severe, for the statistician/scientists among you, being more that two standard deviations away from the mean)even though I have read all the research and my brain feels that there isn’t any evidence of a link, my heart wonders.

    I honestly feel that i did the right thing to try and protect my children’s health by vaccinating them. I don’t regret my decisions. But watching CJ’s (my son’s) progression from a seemingly advanced little boy at 10 months to one who wouldn’t (or couldn’t) talk almost at all at 2 years old (he is 3 1/2 now) made me rethink and reexamine a whole lot of things I never thought I would.

    With significant amounts of speech therapy CJ is turning things around and he hasn’t been diagnosed as autistic (in general, those diagnoses are not made until a little older than he is now, and I am hopeful it won’t come to that).

    But still, the heart, it wonders.

  9. paidtwice Says:

    PS: Both my children have had thimerisol-(mercury)-free vaccines.

  10. tracy ho Says:

    Sad case to know that , if thing can be prove & prevention for others .

    You have our support , take care

  11. JHS Says:

    Thanks for participating in this week’s Carnival of Family Life: St. Patrick’s Day Edition at Colloquium! The Carnival will be live at midnight (Pacific time) on March 17, 2008, so drop by and check out all of the wonderful submissions included this week! Happy St. Patrick’s Day to you!

  12. FitBuff.com's Total Mind and Body Fitness Blog Says:

    Total Mind and Body Fitness Blog Carnival 41…

    Monday is Blog Carnivals Day. A Blog Carnival is basically a collection of articles or blog posts, all relating to a similar subject, that are gathered together for your viewing pleasure. You can quickly and conveniently see a list of Article Titles a…

  13. Blue Licorice Says:

    I totally agree that families whose children have become autistic after shots should be compensated because we are all forced to give our children these shots or else they cannot attend neither daycare nor school. And I have said for years that there is something in either our food or water sources causing these children to be so hyperactive. Look at young children when you are out; 99% of them are extremely hyper and are having to receive medications for parents to be able to control them. Now they say they are finding medications in our water!!! Imagine that.

  14. Jesse Says:

    Hi,well I learnt a whole lot,thanks for the post…it raises a lot of issues that we all need answers to :)

  15. mamam Says:

    Personally, I don’t believe autism is caused by vaccines. However, I do believe it’s possible something in the vaccines may trigger the onset of autism in someone predisposed to it. I still don’t think the benefits offered by vaccines are outweighed by the risks. There’s a great debate about vaccines and autism at http://www.opposingviews.com/questions/are-autism-and-vaccines-linked Several experts from both sides debate the issue and make some interesting points.

  16. irina: mylifeandart.typepad.com Says:

    I was born in Russia and here is what my mom told me. I was a perfect child before my baby vaccinations began. After a required vaccination round, I became very nervous and was always crying. Myself, I remember my non-stop crying for any reason whatsoever until age 12 or so.

    As a grown up and an MD by education, I avoid any type of vaccines, as well as any type of medications, if I can help it.

    Instead, I practice yoga, watch what I eat and do a lot of physical work, it works for me.

  17. Kevin Says:

    Total BS. It’s a much more serious issue not getting ones child vaccinated. Please provide real peer reviewed research that says otherwise. All studies thus far have found no connection.

 
Leave a Reply

Previous: Lowering Cholesterol Without Prescription Drugs
Next: A Wii Bit Addicted